| Steve Harden, President of LifeWings Partners LLC |
 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The Pulse
A bi-monthly newsletter from LifeWings Partners LLC
|
December 2007
|
|
|
Sharpening the Saw: A Message from The
President
"What we have here, is a failure to
communicate."
This line from the movie, "Cool Hand Luke," is well
known and often repeated among flight crews. There
is something about the "I'm-the-king-of-my-own-
destiny" role played by Paul Newman that resonates
with most pilots.
The line is often used, only half in jest, whenever a
pilot realizes a communication error has just
happened. Because the movie is so famous among
pilots, everyone instantly knows the reference and the
intent of the remark. Quoting the line brings a smile to
the lips while also having the effect of redoubling
efforts to ensure effective communication takes place.
What is not as obvious to non-aviators is the
phrase, “…failure to communicate…” represents six
different possible errors or failures. And, without
knowing which of the six reasons has caused the
ineffective communication, it is almost impossible to
fix the error. Case in point: I recently led a workshop
for a healthcare system in south Florida. The purpose
of the workshop was to bring together Labor/Delivery
teams from several of the system’s hospitals to
discuss a recent spate of sentinel events. Many of the
adverse outcomes included both maternal and fetal
deaths.
Our first order of business was to have each hospital
brief the others on their own incident and discuss root
causes. Despite being in the same system, few of the
hospitals had any knowledge of the events in the other
hospitals, even though the root causes were similar.
When the assembled teams all had a baseline
knowledge of each of the events, I mixed the groups
so each team had representation from each member
hospital. Next, I asked the teams to identify the root
causes common to all of the adverse events covered
in the briefings.
It will come as no surprise the number one ranked
root cause, common to all the events, was a "failure to
communicate." I then asked the groups to develop a
strategy to address that root cause which could be
applied across the system. Here, the group
struggled. "Failure to communicate" was too broad of
an issue for them to fix - it encompasses too many
different types of errors. The discussion and
momentum stalled. The teams needed a much more
specific definition of the problem to be able to devise a
specific remedy.
So I conducted a primer on the specific reasons
communication fails. Those are:
- Failure to brief the plan and develop a shared
mental model of the plan of care;
- Failure to speak up and be assertive with
concerns about the impending action or decision;
- Failure to clarify confusion or ask questions;
- Failure to acknowledge communication or "close
the loop."
- Failure to ask for, or provide, feedback or a "read
back" on critical information;
- Failure to use standard terminology.
Armed with this knowledge, the groups re-examined
each event and determined which of the specific
reasons listed above was the root cause for the failed
or ineffective communications. After much discussion,
the consensus was "failure to speak up and be
assertive with concerns."
With this specific issue identified, it was much easier
to devise a training plan to remedy the real source of
the "failure to communicate."
So the next time you find yourself saying, "This was a
failure to communicate" when you analyze why you
didn't achieve the desired results, remember to dig a
little deeper and identify the real root cause of the
failure to communicate. Continue to ask "And why did
that happen?" until you can't come up with any other
answer. When you have drilled down to the absolute
bottom root cause, it's more than likely one or more of
these six reasons will become apparent. Then, and
only then, will you have a specific issue which you can
address successfully.
"A problem well defined is a problem half solved."
Best regards,
Steve

Stephen W. Harden LifeWings President
|
|
LifeWings is Going Lean!
LifeWings is on their way to becoming a Lean
organization with the help of Senior Advisor to the
University of Toyota, Matthew May.
At its essence, Lean is the principle, ingrained in every
employee and manager's mind and practices, that
they are personally and primarily responsible for
incrementally making their job better, more
streamlined, more value added, every single day. It is
a culture that values personal continuous quality
improvement. Toyota processes over one million
improvement ideas from their employees every year.
As a result, they are the world's largest and most
profitable automobile manufacturer.
Hospitals may be embracing the adoption of Lean
principles in the way they design the delivery of care
even faster than their adoption of simulation. This is a
growing market demand to which Lifewings has
responded.
We've be working with one of the premiere faculty
members of Toyota University to learn how to become
a Lean organization ourselves and then seek to
embed Lean practices into our consulting services for
our clients.
Going forward, to be successful our clients must
become owners and not just renters of the technology
and services we provide, and using the practices of
Lean will help them create a culture of continuous
improvement around our methods.
By February of 2008 LifeWings will be a company that
has Lean embedded into its daily work practices
(leading by example), and we will also embed Lean
into our Hardwired Safety Tools workshops. We will
provide services faster, more realistically, and with
better methods for permanent improvements for our
clients.
Our new company motto…THINK LEAN!
|
|
Skills and Tools: Get Better Today
The Shared Mental Model
Every healthcare team should have a good Shared
Mental Model. The Shared Mental is important
because true team coordination depends on it; each
team member is able to predict what other team
members are going to do. In addition, the better the
model is, the faster the error correction rate. Everyone
has a picture of what it should look like. With this
simple tool in place team performance improves and
the inevitable errors of the human care provider are
detected, trapped, and corrected before they harm the
organization or patient.
Here are four questions that should be answered for a
successful Shared Mental Model:
What is happening?
Make sure that each team member has an accurate
assessment of the situation. Does everyone on the
team know what should be happening? The only way
to know for sure is if you have done an adequate
briefing of the game plan.
What will I do?
Everyone on the team must know what their role is
and how to execute that role. Everyone should
understand the exact procedures and sequences to
follow. Each team member should also understand
what the leader expects them to do.
How will I do it?
Team members must also know precisely what to
expect from one another. Who is going to do what?
And when?
Who does what?
You must know what others will do. If you don't know
what your teammates are going to accomplish, you
cannot effectively coordinate your own activities.
Finally, when you have completed your briefing you
must ask yourself the following questions:
- Does everyone really know what is happening?
- Does everyone know what they will do?
- Does everyone know how they will do it?
- Does everyone know what the other team
members will do?
If you cannot answer yes to any of these questions
you must re-brief.
"When a team outgrows individual performance
and learns team confidence, excellence becomes a
reality."
-Joe Paterno
Find out more about Skills Based Training
|
|
Success Stories: Reported Results from Organizations Implementing CRM-based Safety and Quality Programs
Improvement in Employee Satisfaction Surveys
with LifeWings Teamwork Training and Tools
Specifically, in an academic health center LifeWings
worked with the office of the CMO. The goal was to
improve staff satisfaction. The staff realized that not
only is turnover costly in terms of replacement and
recruitment costs, their care-giving teams need
greater permanence to cut down on teamwork and
communication errors.
The leadership wanted teamwork training that
fostered a sense community among the staff and that
would change the way the staff felt about themselves
and the institution for which they worked.
The LifeWings teamwork training and tools
implementation projects gave the hospital leadership
the ingredients to meet their goal. The hospital found
that employees (as measured by an Employee
Satisfaction Survey) that attended the teamwork
training and worked in departments using the
Hardwired Safety Tools had a greater sense of
teamwork and satisfaction with their place of work
than those employees that had not attended the
training and did not work in departments using the
safety tools.
Read about results hospitals are getting using an aviation-based patient safety program
|
|
Leadership Toolkit: Skills for Sustaining an Enduring Cultural Change
Guidelines for Leaders When Working Toward
Project Success, Part II:
In the last issue of The Pulse (September 2007), we
explored the first five guidelines for leaders to use
when working toward CRM-project success. Here are
a few more:
- Stay realistic, (we can't cure cancer)
but "Stretch."
- Finish with a sense of accomplishment.
- Expect to do work outside of the formal work
sessions.
- Realize this is all a work in progress - we get
better each time, but we don't have all the
answers.
- Use what works for you - discard what doesn't
(but not just because it's different).
*Adapted from Dr. Curt Rimmerman, The
Cleveland Clinic
"Creating a culture of safety requires attention not
only to the design of our task and process, but to
conditions under which we work - hours, schedules
and workloads; how we train every member of the
healthcare team to participate in the quest for safer
patient care."
-Lucian L. Leape
BMJ, 2000
Find out more about Leadership Development
|
|
For Further Reading: Our Featured Article
Lean Thinking for Knowledge Work
By Matthew E. May
"Lean thinking at Toyota looks nothing like most
oversimplified, rule centered and expert driven
corporate improvement programs. There is no one
best way, no 10-step model, no sensei
(teacher or master) and no multiphase
implementation plan. Instead, lean thinking conveys a
higher viewpoint that empowers knowledge workers
to become independent goal seekers who leverage
deeper problem solving skills and critical thinking
capabilities in service to customers."
View full article here!
|
|
News You Can Use: To Implement a CRM-based Safety and Quality Improvement Program
"Two Lean Tools You Can Use to
Improve Processes at Your Site," is an article
by Donald Bryant, who puts out a free monthly
newsletter, "Making Good Healthcare Better" to help
healthcare providers meet their challenges.
"Going Lean in
Health Care." IHI Innovation Series White
Paper. Cambridge, MA: Institute for Healthcare
Improvement; 2005. (Available on www.IHI.org.) This
publication explores how Lean management
principles are being successfully applied to the
healthcare industry.
"Commentary: Lean Thinking Can Improve Health
Care" is written by Steven B. Bonner and
appeared in the April 2007 issue of Health Care
News. This article is about how hospitals can do
more with less (article found on the Heartland
Institute).
|
|
Ask the Innovators: Road Blocks of Aviation-Based Project Implementation
Q:
To date, what is the greatest challenge your
organization faces with CRM implementation?
A:
It would be consistency of application with the tools. A
tool is only as good as the people using the tool and it
has to be used all the time. We have had great
success in improvement of communication,
teamwork, and satisfaction both physician and
nursing.
Things are going great here. The LifeWings program
changed the culture in a thinking mode of if you find it
fix it. We have staff working to develop tools almost
weekly for any issue we define as a problem. As for
measurable outcomes, we do a procedure brief 100%
of the time, we have caught allergies etc. in the time
out process we have prior to procedure. We have tools
that identify problems before they occur.
Jennifer S. Cord RN MSN
Director Women's Services
Provena United Samaritans Medical Center
Recent Innovators:
Texas Orthopedic Hospital-Houston, TX
Fall Seminar, "Creating a Team"
Salem Hospital-Salem, OR
L&D, NICU, & Mother / Baby Depts.
Texas Health Resources-Arlington, TX
Teamwork Skills Workshop for Risk
Managers
SSM St. Mary's Health Center-St. Louis,
MO
Risk Assessment / Training Visit
Texas Medical Liability Trust-Austin, TX
Fall Seminar Series
St. John's Lutheran Hospital-Libby, MT
Teamwork Skills Workshop
Got a question that you would like to see
answered in one of our newsletters? Well, tell us
about it! Send your question to
kdebra@SaferPatients.com with the email
subject as "Road Block Question."
If you would like a reference for any of our clients,
please contact K.C. DeBra at
kdebra@SaferPatients.com or (901) 844-
9226.
Forward this newsletter now!
|
|
Streams in the Desert: Thoughts and Stories to Inspire
The Quest for Excellence
On November 2, 2007 The Nebraska Medical Center
(NMC) was presented with the Nebraska Hospital
Association "Quest for Excellence" award based on
their application titled "Improving Cardiovascular
Patient Safety: Implementation of Crew Resource
Management". This award is given each year in
recognition of "the highest level of professional
acknowledgement in Nebraska's hospital quality
improvement arena". The application focused on the
implementation process of Crew Resource
Management (CRM) to promote cardiovascular patient
safety in the OR, Cardiac Catheterization and
Electrophysiology Lab, as well as the results achieved
thus far. Although a very high level of patient safety in
procedure based areas was already in place at the
NMC, CRM was pursued as a strategy to take the
organization to an even higher level of excellence.
The application acknowledges the training by and
collaborative relationship with LifeWings Partners
LLC. LifeWings provided the initial leadership and
employee training and tools development facilitation.
In June of 2006, two NMC employees were trained to
teach the LifeWings curriculum "in-house" in order to
provide ongoing instruction and mentoring and
sustain forward momentum for the program. To date,
258 physicians, 286 residents and 501 staff have
attended CRM training at the NMC.
This represents over 99% of the staff and physicians
in the procedure based areas within the NMC that
were originally targeted for CRM training.
Implementation of and participation in CRM was
declared a mandated process by the hospital's Board
of Directors, and actively supported by the executive
level of the organization. This level of championship
is considered essential to the success achieved thus
far. Lessons learned include the importance of
customizing tools for each procedure based area; the
development of tools that are focused, brief and
obvious in their value to achieve buy-in; and having
the "right staff and physicians" on the tool and
implementation teams.
Although not without its ongoing challenges,
implementation success is measured by looking to
the large body of varying kinds of "good catches" that
occur on a regular basis, compared to our adverse
event tracking. Surveys seeking feedback on
the "Culture of Patient Safety" demonstrate significant
post implementation improvement in the perception of
staff, physicians and residents. An impressive
increase in un-eventful cases post CRM
implementation has also been identified.
Mary Ellen Uphoff
Mater Black Belt, Six Sigma Dept.
The Nebraska Medical Center-Omaha
|
|
Our Gift To You
Book Competition!
The Elegant Solution
Toyota's Formula for Mastering Innovation
By Matthew E. May
Senior Advisor to the University of Toyota
"For the first time, an insider reveals the formula
behind Toyota's unceasing quest to innovate and do
more with less, a philosophy that has made it one of
the ten most profitable companies in the world (and
worth more than FM, Ford, DaimlerChrysler, and
Honda combined.) "
The following short "manifesto" based on Matthew
May's book (a synopsis called "Elegant Solutions:
Breakthrough Thinking the Toyota Way") is available in
free PDF form at http://www.changethis.com/29.01.ElegantSolution
s
Want to win an autographed copy this book?
In "Elegant Solutions: Breakthrough Thinking the
Toyota Way," Matthew May mentions "An elegant
solution is quite often a single tiny BLANK
idea that changes everything."
Fill in the blank by emailing your response to K.C.
DeBra at kdebra@SaferPatients.com, and if
your answer is correct you will automatically be placed
in a drawing to win an autographed copy of Matthew
May's book (you must also include your contact
information along with your mailing address to be
eligible for the drawing). The drawing will take place
on December 13, 2007.
Good luck!
Buy Matthew May's book here!
|
|
|
LifeWings In The News
Bill of Health - Hospital Safety Plan
The LifeWings patient safety improvement program
was recently featured on the PBS Nightly Business
Report.
Read PBS Transcript Now!
|
|